Hi,
We have an RODC in a perimeter network that is configured through Sites and Services to handle logon requests for the perimeter networks subnets. We've seen some strange behavior with the logons on this network though.
* If a user logs on a server in the perimeter network, and is a member of "allowed RODC Password Replication" group, and has their password prepopulated, the logon is near instant
* If a user logs on a server in the perimeter network, and is a member of "allowed RODC Password Replication" group, but doesn't have their password prepopulated, the logon takes around 20 seconds on first logon, and near instant on any subsequent
logons on any server in the perimeter network. (the password is now cached)
* If a user logs on a server in the perimeter network, and is not a member of "allowed RODC password replication" group, all logons take around 20 seconds.
We've done a few traces on the servers with Wireshark, and during the logons without cached or prepopulated passwords, we see communcation with the RODC at logon, then a long pause (about 20 seconds), and then continued communcation with the RODC, and the
logon continues.
During this pause, we see the server trying to communicate with one of our RWDC's outside the perimeter network (on port 445), which is not possible, and we believe this is what's causing the delay in logon. From what I've gathered this is not normal behavior.
We've re-verified that the sites are set up correctly, as nltest /dsgetdc:domain.local returns the RODC, and correct perimiter network Site.
We've also checked netlogon logs, but haven't gotten any answers from that either. Though occasionally we see DC locator requesting a writable DC, and dropping the RODC with reason "responder is not a writable server", which is correct ofcourse.
Though we're not sure if this is the logon request or some other service we've got running on the server, so we've not gone further into investigating this at this time.
Any tips on what we could check next?
The RODC is a 2012R2 server in a 2012R2 Domain (both domain and forest level functionality raised), and the memberservers are all also 2012R2 servers.
Best regards,
Pouria